Written by the team behind Verdo, which is first on this list. Every other entry names something that tool does better than Verdo, because a roundup that doesn't is an advertisement. Competitor details checked 28 September 2026 — verify current features and pricing on each vendor's site.

Last verified: 28 September 2026

1. Verdo

Best for internal decisions that need an owner and an outcome.

A decision engine rather than a polling app. Single-choice voting, a majority or consensus rule set before the vote, an optional named owner, a status model that outlives the vote, an audit trail, and a 30-day review asking the owner (or the workspace owner, if none is named) whether the decision actually worked.

  • Strong pointsThe only tool here with an authority rule fixed before voting starts. An optional named owner, who the outcome review goes to. Priced per workspace ($49 a month on Pro), so including fifteen people in a decision costs nothing extra.
  • Where it stopsNo surveys, standups, pulse checks or trivia. If you want engagement tooling, this is the wrong product. No free tier — both plans are card-backed with a 7-day trial. One question per decision by design, which is a limitation if you wanted a questionnaire.

2. Polly

Best for feedback, surveys and team rituals.

A mature survey and engagement platform: pulse checks, standups, retro feedback, suggestion boxes, word clouds. Anonymous responses, scheduling and recurrence, CSV export, Google Sheets and Jira integrations, webhooks and an API on paid plans.

  • Strong pointsFar broader than Verdo — surveys, standups and engagement in one place. Strong anonymity controls, including anonymity from the person who sent the poll. Long track record and a large install base.
  • Where it stopsNo concept of an accountable owner on a result. No authority rule — you interpret the numbers yourself. Priced per licence, which adds up as you include more people.

3. Simple Poll

Best for fast, low-ceremony polls.

More capable than its name suggests: single select, multi select, ranked choice, scale rating and short answer, plus scheduled and recurring polls, closing after a set duration, reminders to non-responders, anonymous polls on the paid plan, and CSV export.

  • Strong pointsAlmost no learning curve — type the command, add options, done. Free tier that is genuinely usable for small teams. Ranked choice and anonymity without leaving the poll model.
  • Where it stopsA poll closes and that is the end of its life — no status, no follow-up. No owner and no rule for what the result obliges anyone to do. Anonymous and multiple choice sit behind the paid plan.

4. Client sign-off tools

Best for decisions involving people outside your workspace.

A category rather than one product: tools built for client and stakeholder sign-off rather than internal votes. Stakeholders typically respond through a browser link with no account, no app and no Slack seat, and each decision closes as a timestamped record you can hand to a client.

  • Strong pointsExternal voters need nothing — no account, no install, no workspace invite. Timestamped records designed to be shared with a client or attached to a project. Built around approval by people who will never join your Slack.
  • Where it stopsUsually a single approve-or-decline model. Rarely carry a named owner, a decision lifecycle or an outcome review. Aimed at agencies and services firms rather than internal product or engineering teams.

5. Notion + Slack

Best for teams that already live in Notion.

Not a decision tool — a database you maintain by hand, with Slack notifications on top. A decision-log template, a discipline about filling it in, and a reminder to review it. Plenty of teams run this successfully.

  • Strong pointsFree if you already pay for Notion, and infinitely customisable. The log sits next to your specs and project docs rather than in another tool. No vendor decision to make.
  • Where it stopsNo voting, no deadline enforcement, no reminders — every step is manual. It works exactly as long as someone keeps filling it in, which is usually about six weeks. No audit trail: a row can be edited afterwards with no record that it was.

The verdict

If you need a decision with a method, a deadline, an owner and a record — and you want to know a month later whether it worked — Verdo is the only tool here that closes the whole loop. If your decisions involve clients or other people outside your workspace, a dedicated client sign-off tool is the right choice instead: one built around external voters who will never install anything. And if what you actually want is to know how the team is feeling, buy a survey tool and don't overthink it.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best decision-making tool for Slack teams?
It depends on the job. For internal decisions that need an owner, a rule and a record, Verdo is the only tool here that does the full loop. For feedback and team rituals, Polly. For fast lightweight polls, Simple Poll. For decisions involving clients or other people outside your workspace, a dedicated client sign-off tool. For teams already deep in Notion who want a manual log, Notion plus Slack notifications.
What is the difference between a poll app and a decision tool?
A poll measures what people picked. A decision tool turns that into something actionable: an authority rule agreed before the vote so the result is not reinterpreted afterwards, a named owner accountable for follow-through, a status showing what happened to the decision, and a review asking whether it worked. Polling apps are not missing these by oversight — they have no reason to carry them.
Is there a free tool for making decisions in Slack?
Simple Poll and Polly both have free tiers capped by monthly responses, and Notion plus Slack notifications costs nothing extra if you already pay for Notion. Verdo has no free tier: Pro opens with a 7-day card-backed trial.
Can I use more than one?
Most teams do, and should. The tools above are good at different things and they do not conflict. A common split is a polling app for the lightweight and recurring, and a decision tool for the handful of calls each quarter that someone will have to justify.
How much does Verdo cost?
Pro is $49 a month, priced per workspace rather than per person, with one workspace per subscription and a 7-day free trial. Card required. Cancel anytime during the trial with no charge.

Try Verdo in your workspace.

Pick one decision your team has been circling and run it end to end — method, deadline, owner, record.

7-day free trial. Card required. Cancel anytime during the trial with no charge.